EU Friday – 20 November

Home / Uncategorized / EU Friday – 20 November

EU Friday

Welcome to Better Europe’s weekly update on EU Affairs.

NGO FUNDING REPORT: NO GUN, SHOOT ANYWAY

After a year of hunting for NGO lobby scandals, there is still no smoking gun. After examining 119 funding contracts between the Commission and NGOs and consultants, 63 of which were flagged for “reputational risk”, the Parliament’s “scrutiny working group” this week discussed its report on the “scandal”. The conclusions? No wrongdoing, no financial misconduct, no proof the Commission required anyone to lobby the Parliament, no influence on legislation. But even if there is no smoking gun, the EPP and ECR MEPs drafting the report managed to spin the media, drip-feeding parts of the report to selected news outlets since the end of last week. By midweek, the news of the forthcoming not-so-smoking-gun report reached Figaro and Tagesschau, relaying “secret contracts” of activists paid to drag German coal plants to court, only to admit in a footnote that it was an executive agency, not the Commission, that handed out the money. In fact, Dutch co-rapporteur Dirk Gotink had already conceded in February that “the problem that we’re pursuing here is not to establish whether things are illegal, it is to establish whether politically it is undesirable”. So there might not be a smoking gun, but there is certainly plenty of shooting: 23 recommendations, including a full ban on operating grants for civil society organisations and a case-by-case ban on project grants for organisations “found in breach” of the non-lobby requirement. The Socialists, Liberals, Greens and the Left might have been quick to dismiss the report to be adopted next week as “a political instrument”, but the damage is done in the mainstream media: “EU financed environmental lobby and court cases against decision to keep coal plants running”, headlined one news outlet in the Member State that Gotink knows best. As the EEB put it: “you cannot manufacture a scandal, investigate your own allegations, find no evidence to substantiate them, and then use the same accusations to argue that organisations should be defunded”. More shots next week as the report should be adopted – without amendments.

BANKING UNION, ONE MERGER AT A TIME

If the legislative route is too difficult, perhaps merging banks is an easier way to achieve Banking Union. So the Commission this week cleared Italian UniCredit’s takeover of Germany’s Commerzbank. Competition chief Teresa Ribera proudly presented the deal as proof that cross-border bank mergers are possible, while insisting it is “not a green light for every single merger in the banking sector”. Minor hiccup: the German government’s share of 13% comes with a right to appoint two supervisory board seats, which the government was happy to give up in exchange for a broad set of promises, set out in a letter from CEO Andrea Orcel to German Finance Minister Lars Klingbeil. Frankfurt can keep the headquarters and the listing, and the lending to German companies is to grow. What is not in the letter — the roughly 7,000 job cuts in UniCredit’s plan. The letter does promise to respect German labour law, including the practise of having employee representatives taking half of the seats on Commerzbank’s supervisory board… but only until 2030. That sounds a lot like the contentious issue in the ongoing 28th regime for company law saga, better known as “EU Inc”. In the Council’s October position, member states can impose co-determination rules on an EU Inc active in their country. So why is co-determination essential in company law, and just a bargaining chip in a bank merger?

COP31: DO AS I SAY, NOT AS I DO

COP31 in Antalya was always planned to be an intermediate COP: no new targets, only implementation of the old ones, so the EU’s attention was elsewhere. The first, eighteen-page draft of the outcome agreement was dismissed by Climate Commissioner Wopke Hoekstra as a “shopping list” that could make the process “untenable”; the second, published on Thursday, is nine pages and no longer mentions coal, oil or gas. The transition away from fossil fuels: gone. The 120 billion dollar adaptation target: gone. What survives, softened, is what was already said in UNEP’s autumn report: exceeding 1.5 degrees is unavoidable, and the task is now to keep the overshoot short and return below it by 2100. But while the world waits in suspense to read the final COP31 statement at the end of this week, the EU’s leaders in negotiations on Wednesday night agreed to postpone some of the block’s own climate rules. The EU is committed to “shielding our citizens from high energy prices”, the methane rules for oil, gas and coal importers slide to 2029. But this is just reporting: importers get more time to document how much methane their fuels emit. Nothing is banned, no cargo is stopped at the border; and how unmeasured gas becomes cheaper gas has not been explained. As the EPP’s negotiator, Dimitris Tsiodras, explained: “We are not suspending the methane regulation but ensuring its effective implementation”.